Viewing Great, Timing Difficult

Reprinted from blog at Transit of Venus Project, courtesy of Steven van Roode

A Recap of the Transit of Venus on June 5, 2012

I’ve never surfed a big ocean wave before, but I imagine it’s something like the transit of Venus. You prepare, you see it coming, you paddle franticly to catch the right spot. Then, for a fleeting moment you stand up, ride a mass of towering energy, delight in a surreal moment in a tunnel, then feel the watery bulk flow underneath you as you emerge on the wave’s backside, thankfully intact. For the last couple of weeks I’ve been floating on the backside of that transit of Venus wave, and it’s been quietly exhilarating.

Eight years of anticipation peaked with a gorgeous June 5 in northern Indiana. The day got underway early with site preparations, as a tent was raised and brought to life with with electricity, cable, internet, and sound. Of course, the phone was ringing as last minute seekers of solar shades and interviews dialed in to the day’s events. There was nothing left to do with the website, as that ship had set sail. I reset the Countdown Clock for the 2117 transit of Venus, some 38,000+ days in the future, and walked away from the computer.  Our Transit of Venus (TROVE) celebration was underway.

Irvin Stanley of USNO expedition in tent on Kerguelen Island, 1874Shortly after noon a group of descendants of Irvin Stanley arrived, having come from Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, and California. Irvin Stanley was the Assistant Photographer for the US Naval Observatory (USNO) expeditions to Kerguelen Island (1874) and Patagonia (1882), and USNO Librarian Sally Bosken had generously provided many artifacts from the expedition archives. A highlight of the transit of Venus experience has been learning about and following this one person, Irvin Stanley, through the travails of exploration in a previous century. Now his family was touring regional transit of Venus highlights, with more than just the celestial sight on tap.

First up was an exhibit of transit of Venus art by high school students. Then I presented a talk centered on Irvin Stanley and the greater quest to find the Astronomical Unit from timed observations and photographs of the event from widely separated (hence, remote) locations. I wish I had had more time to peruse the family photo album that someone brought, but the family was ushered onto the motor coach and was off to the next stop–the Harris Branch Library, site of a transit of Venus display of artifacts and an art exhibit in pastel.

June 5 was the last day of school for the Penn-Harris-Madison (PHM) school district, and Art Klinger’s astronomy class students began setting up telescopes and viewing devices in the field near the tent. Over an hour before first contact, spectators were showing up as we secured solar filters to telescopes with bright orange duct tape. I gave one last frenzied lecture in the theater before returning to the scopes outside A bustle of activity ensued until suddenly hundreds of people had gathered and there was talk of the transit beginning imminently. Scott Potosky quieted the music and piped in a WWV time signal for anyone at a scope who wanted to capture the moments of contact by that audible method. Everybody had taken their first look at the sun with solar shades, which in itself yielded a lot of oohs and ahhs, before Venus even took the stage.
Observers gather to witness 2012 transit of VenusVenus entered near the one o’clock position on the sun, the planet not easily discernible to the naked eye as it worked its way across the limb. People waited patiently in lines to view through telescopes, a sight complemented by two significant bands of sunspot groups. I occasionally glanced in a telescope, but was strangely removed as I emceed the event for a growing audience. As second contact approached, I cut to the front of a line and planted myself. I felt like the narrator in Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr.’s, The Flaneur. There I was, face to face with Venus, having a conversation with her at internal contact.

Determining moment of internal contact was difficult.  Here the observer is actually looking through an H-alpha telescope, which would not have been used for timing the event.My overriding impression of the moment was, “Damn, determining the time of contact is not easy.” I tried to imagine all of our predecessors trying to discern an exact moment when they felt convinced Venus was edge-to-edge with the sun. I understand Crabtree not recording the transit in writing. I understand Rittenhouse becoming overcome with emotion. I understand Cook’s time not being in synch with his shipmates’ times. I understand the expedition preparations that insist on total concentration and absence of distractions leading up to the transit, conditions that were lacking at the public event.

While the sight through a telescope was enthralling, I experienced an undeniable uncertainty and lack of confidence in my timing. Despite my familiarity with what to expect and my having witnessed the 2004 transit of Venus, I could easily have been off by 30 seconds. The sun was at about 30 degrees of altitude with no clouds obstructing the view, but Venus seemed to linger on the solar edge. I looked for the planet to separate clearly from the sun, but when that didn’t happen I tried to see if the horns of the sun had reconnected. Was that a minimalistic black drop effect I witnessed that suspended time? How did so many of those earlier explorers seemingly fare better?  I wasn’t at the eyepiece long enough to look for other phenomena, like the aureole effect.

Lou Sandock of YMCA AstroCamp assists a young observerFour monitors in the tent showed other perspectives. Feeds were coming in from NASA’s webcast in Hawaii, news channels, and websites like Steven van Roode’s transitofvenus.nl and my own transitofvenus.org. David Wyatt tracked Venus through a video camera that was hooked into a telescope and broadcast on a monitor. Another person projected a vast image of the transit onto a screen. Some people saw the transit through white light filters and a hydrogen-alpha telescope provided by AstroCamp of YMCA Camp Eberhart in Three Rivers, MI. Of course, a couple of telescopes were equipped with Sun Funnels, which yielded a projected image of the sunspots and of Venus in silhouette.

A few clouds moved in, thankfully after first and second contact, so during breaks in the action I demonstrated with a paper plate why transits come in 8-year pairs separated by over a century. I solicited and answered questions, pleased by the inquiries while realizing what I had previously left unsaid while narrating the event. The best memories are from the quiet moments when I shut up.

A crowd dons solar shades and sees VenusFor example, after one extended cloud was ready to give the sun back to us, everyone realized when the sun was about to emerge from the well defined edge. I watched the crowd as they lifted their heads in unison and donned solar shades just as the sun brightened their faces.

During the whole event, a few local businesses that were supportive of science hawked their wares. Victorian Pantry served its Black Drop Effect Coffee, a smooth dark roast that was packaged with a design borrowed from the stained glass windows of St. Michael’s Church in Hoole, England. Pizza Transit (yes, its pre-existing name) had both a Transit of Venus pizza and a Black Drop Effect pizza for sale. Taylor Design sold commemorative t-shirts, one of which has Worlds on Tour printed on the backside with the dates of past and future transits of Venus. Rock on.

Nitzschke's illustration of a transit at sunsetPeople had been coming and going from the PHM site for the duration of the transit, and I joined the early departures. My heart was set on watching the transit underway at sunset from Warren Dunes State Park in Sawyer, Michigan, overlooking Lake Michigan. I had to see the Nitzschke-like view, what I consider an iconic transit image.

While I was driving to that lakeside destination, I realized other local observing sites with telescopes were drawing large crowds–New Carlisle Public Library (160 people), Andrews University (500 people), LaSalle Intermediate Academy (400 people), University of Notre Dame (~2,000 people).  Each was staffed by dedicated transit of Venus enthusiasts.

Don't know if she saw Venus, but the view of the sun was great.We had distributed about 6,000 pairs of solar shades to people ranging from church pastors to juveniles at the detention center, so hopefully the shades were pressed into service. Venus was readily apparent naked eye to most people when it got away from the edge of the sun, albeit just a small dot on the sun.

As we arrived at Warren Dunes, a chilly breeze kept a red warning flag blowing stiffly. The Kalamazoo Astronomical Society had stationed itself on a large concrete pad overlooking the beach and lake, with a fabulous assortment of telescopes and observing devices, from grand to humble. Over a thousand people had gotten a glimpse of the transit through their gear that day, and sunset was approaching. I can’t emphasize enough how beautiful the sunset was, with only the slightest of wispy clouds near the horizon that added character to the spectacle rather than obscured it. Seen in filtered telescopes, Venus contorted into a variety of shapes as her blackness or absence of light flickered through the thickest atmosphere.

A clear view of the sun as it sets over Lake Michigan; from Warren Dunes State Park, Michigan.

The time came to abandon telescopes and solar shades. With the orange-ish sun plunging into the water, Venus was visible to the naked eye. I saw Venus at times appear to be nearly square, like four pixels on a monitor, and then it would momentarily disappear completely before re-emerging as an obvious spot on the sun. At one point the black blemish was above and right of a thin cloud line across the sun; soon it was below the thin line. Eventually Venus was gone, set below the horizon. The spectators watched the remainder of the sunset and cheered, sending well wishes to Venus for the next 105.5 years.

From there a modest crowd and the bus tour went to The Livery microbrewery in Benton Harbor, MI, where musician Venitia Sekema was performing an excellent musical set. We propped up the Transit of Venus Time Keg for people to write any last comments to denizens of the 22nd century. Shortly after 11:00 p.m. EDT we broadcast live via Slooh, showing some more transit of Venus art on display at the microbrewery. And, of course, we quaffed some Venusian ale, which had been crafted specifically for the celestial phenomenon. To see the half hour of our live broadcast, watch from about 0:52 to 1:23 of the Slooh Space Camera Transit of Venus Part 3.

Shortly before midnight, everybody inside the pub went out to the back patio and watched the International Space Station pass nearly overhead at magnitude -3.3. Onboard the ISS, astronaut Don Pettit would have been between the second and third contacts, though we were in the dark below. Again we cheered, wishing Don well in his photographing of the transit from the ISS cupola.

Observers leave messages in the Transit of Venus Time Keg on June 5Everyone was clearly getting tired from a long day. While I had intended to seal the Time Keg for its long storage, we opted not to do so that evening. I figured there may be a couple of items to add before we hastily closed the lid for good. If you have any contents that you wish to include, email me ( CLOAKING ) to see if there is room and time. I’d like to wrap it up soon.

The week after the transit of Venus has been a time to decompress and re-connect with family and friends. From my perspective, much more has passed by than just 6+ hours of Venus on the sun. It’s been a long, fun ride, and I’m grateful to many people for their respective roles in this adventure. There is still much more to do, of course, but on a different level of urgency. Thanks for being a part of the 20th century transit of Venus experience, especially to everyone who contributed to the outreach effort.

What a sight. What a day. Surf was definitely up.
   

Crowd Gathers to Witness the 2004 Transit of Venus

A crowd gathered before sunrise on June 8, 2004, to witness the rare Transit of Venus in Mishawaka, Indiana, USA. Though clouds threatened to obscure the spectacle, the sun emerged in time for the audience to observe through telescopes, rear projection screens, and solar viewers. An audible time signal in the background allowed individuals to time the instant when the black dot of Venus just touched the inside edge of the sun, as global expeditions had done in past centuries. The last transit of Venus in our lifetimes occurs June 5-6, 2012.  YouTube video at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qS1O6C2dQ40.

   

2004 Observing Report-Brian Davis

Date: 8 Jun 2004
Location: Penn High School, Mishawaka, IN, USA (41.68 Lat, -86.11 Lon)
Equipment: XT8 (8" dobsonian reflector), 25mm & 9mm plossl, ultrascopic 2x barlow, Thousand Oaks solar filter
Predicted sunrise: 5:10 AM local time (10:10 UTC), at 59° azimuthrea
Predicted 3rd contact: around 6:03 AM local time, 8° altitude
Predicted 4th contact: around 6:24 AM local time, 11° altitude

[See 2004 Celebration in Mishawaka, IN]

Wonderful event! I observed at a public event that a bunch of us with equipment were recruited for. While I showed the transit to 100+ folks (a lot of kids, nice to see), I had exclusive use for third & fourth contact to *try* to time them. Before that morning I had never used a solar filter - one was provided by the organizers of the event. The result was almost comic: perhaps a dozen 'scopes started franticly trying to locate the Sun as soon as it crested the trees near the horizon around 5:30, almost none with filter-equiped finders and with the Sun too dim (low & in clouds) too be seen in the eyepiece. Minimize the shadow cast by the OTA I hear you say? With the Sun so low & dim, there were no shadows, and we dared not look with the filters off. Eventually everybody located it, and the viewing began.

Venus was a wonderfully inky black perfect disk on the Sun, unmistakable. As others have noted, it seemed larger than I had expected, nice at 48x, with 3rd & 4th contact observed at 96x. The blackness was really noticeable compared to the two small sunspots centrally located. As 3rd contact approached, I started to see what looked like...
 ...a thin thread connected the black disk of Venus to the limb of the Sun. It was hair-fine, and slightly "wrinkly", not razor straight but slightly slack and wriggly. I saw it at least three times, when Venus was perhaps 1/5th of a Venusian diameter or less from the solar limb (did anyone else see this?). As the bridge thinned, it seemed to thin on both sides, as if being drawn apart like a piece of taffy. This was subtle, but it soon formed a wavery bridge of light, trembling to hold Venus within the glowing disk of the Sun. This very quickly gave way to the "black drop": instead of a razor-thin line of light, Venus merged with the edge in a non-uniform way, one instant still within the solar disk, the next breaking the limb of the Sun with a wider-than-it-should-be black gap. I was unprepared for how difficult this made timing the moment of contact (I got 11:05:02 UT - the guy next to me was something like 7 *seconds* earlier, clearly unacceptable... and I'm not sure either of us trusted our own observations on this). As it pushed through the limb, I thought I saw a partial ring of light around it when it was perhaps a quarter of the way out - the guy next to me clearly saw it (not sure what magnification he was using, but he was on a 4" apo), and was very excited. He described it as "horns" to a complete arc (it was never that distinct to me). I *did* notice that from a quarter of the way out to perhaps halfway or even more, the disk of Venus seemed very slightly darker than the sky behind it. I could picture the complete disk of Venus even with half of it off the face of the Sun (perhaps this was my imagination, but it was something I thought I observed... and after all, that's what this is, an observing report :-). 4th contact actually seemed easier to judge (note, this doesn't mean I was any more accurate, just more confident); as Venus departed from the Sun, it formed a rapidly-diminishing very shallow dimple, and I timed 4th contact as the moment when this dimple was lost in the seeing variations in the solar limb.

All in all, we had a fantastic time. Plenty of folks helped out, running 'scopes for the general public, while others MCed the event. The general public was wonderful, really enthusiastic... it was also nice, I must admit, getting to peek through others equipment: I had the XT8 and a TV85 plus a pair of tripod-mounted binoculars, and I suspect I was the bottom end of the equipment list. One guy had a 6" refractor, there were a couple of 10" reflectors, an LX200, several APOs (at least one other TV85), and two 'scopes with H-alpha filters (a coronado & something else). The night before we had a mini-starfest, tagging various (mostly bright) objects in the hazy, light-polluted (but steady!) skies until midnight, then gathering in a tent to watch a webcast of 1st & 2nd contact. Even on TV it was a spellbinding event, and picturing the true three-dimensional situation (the Sun being more than twice as far from Venus as Venus is from us at that moment) made it even more amazing. The dimmest object I managed to find that night was M82 (!!), but Jupiter was nice (well-defined features in the NEB), and M13 and colorful doubles were the public showpieces of the night.

Oh, and somewhere in there I did land 2 hours of sleep in a tent nearby. Didn't hit me at all until the next day, late, when I fell asleep waiting for the shower to warm up. Oops.

Afterthoughts (for the next transit): (1) I need to have some way to photograph through the eyepiece, as well as remembering to take a few "naked eye" (unmagnified) shots of the Sun (I didn't think of it - now *that's* dumb). (2) Observe on higher power (I really could have gone up from 96x, and seeing would have probably supported my next option at 133x with the 9mm). (3) Run a tape recorder to record verbal observations during the event. And maybe, not do the public thing - although it was FANTASTIC, and I wouldn't have missed it for the world, I really want to be isolationist for the critical moments of the next one.

OK, anybody else want to report? Please?
--
Brian Davis
   

2004 Celebration in Mishawaka, IN

June8

A crowd of observers are reflected in a rear projection screen as Venus makes third contact during the 2004 Transit of Venus.

The 2004 transit of Venus was witnessed and celebrated from Mishawaka, Indiana, USA, under very good conditions.  We had successful stargazing the night of June 7; webcasts beginning at midnight (EST); clear skies at sunrise; perhaps 20 quality telescopes and viewing devices; and a crowd of enthusiasts.  As third contact approached, so too did a large bank of low clouds.  However, the clouds cleared in time to capture that elusive moment.   See video.

Brian Davis wrote a descriptive observing report about his experience.

Visually, the transit of Venus at third contact was more rewarding than I had anticipated.  No appreciable black drop effect appeared, on which we could blame diverse timings.  I was taken aback by how difficult it was to discern the exact second of contact.  Only part of it can be attributed to the festival-like atmosphere we sought.

More photos...




Details about the celebration and our experience will be uploaded after we tend to some necessary business--sending many thank-you notes, paying bills, gathering images and stories, and getting some sleep.  In the meantime, we thank the many businesses and individuals who supported our efforts to bring this dynamic solar system experience to our community.  

Media Coverage Continues

dsc03092med.jpg (30969 bytes)
dsc03088med.jpg (39794 bytes)
dsc03085med.jpg (39477 bytes)
dustin0012.JPG (172274 bytes)
kaelin014.JPG (189351 bytes)
3092 3087 3084 dustin012 kaelin014

Preparing the Main Observing Site

dsc03093med.jpg (56240 bytes) 3093 dsc03095med.jpg (49922 bytes)3095 dsc03097med.jpg (49002 bytes)3097 dsc03099med.jpg (52972 bytes)3099 dsc03100med.jpg (55694 bytes)3100
banner010.JPG (162269 bytes)banner010 monitors011.JPG (168931 bytes)monitors011 slaton013.JPG (166647 bytes)
dsc03104med.jpg (58991 bytes)3104 dsc03098med.jpg (50889 bytes)3098 
tentframe03034.jpg (52539 bytes)tentframe3034 tent03036.jpg (42195 bytes)tent3036 phmsign3046.jpg (36694 bytes)phmsign3046
phmsign3047.jpg (37991 bytes)phmsign3047


Webcasts of 1st and 2nd Contacts

dsc03113med.jpg (45795 bytes)3113

June 8, 2004: Transit of Venus at Sunrise

dsc00006.jpg (184209 bytes)006 dsc00025.jpg (167894 bytes)025 dsc00031.jpg (161038 bytes)031 dsc00002.jpg (171400 bytes)002 dsc00017.jpg (189112 bytes)017  dsc00003.jpg (173750 bytes)003 dsc00008.jpg (188728 bytes)008 dsc00010.jpg (179200 bytes)010 

Clouds Threaten Third Contact

dsc00016.jpg (177638 bytes)016

Broadcast of WWV Time Signal, courtesy of  Radio Operator John Fleming (W3GQJ)

dsc03106med.jpg (37663 bytes)3106 dsc03108med.jpg (51516 bytes)3108

Clouds Clear

dsc00023.jpg (169289 bytes)023 dsc00024.jpg (192967 bytes)024 dsc00025.jpg (167894 bytes)025 dsc00030.jpg (169666 bytes)030

Klinger, Bueter, Franken, and Darnell after the 2004 Transit of Venusafterglow.jpg
Image courtesy of Cathy McCormick.

aligning.jpg (16707 bytes)aligning.jpg
Aligning with moon.
darnell.jpg (15463 bytes)darnell.jpg
Observing the moon
lapierre.jpg (31667 bytes)lapierre.jpg 
Preparing scopes.
images courtesy of Don Darnell.

http://www.physics.nd.edu/venus%20at%20phm/index.htm
University of Notre Dame physics students watch the transit of Venus from the PHM site in Mishawaka, IN.

The following table of images are courtesy of Ralph Garhart:

Dh000001.jpg (1145328 bytes)3g001 3g005.jpg (41767 bytes)3g005 3g003.jpg (66433 bytes)3g003 3g010.jpg (42294 bytes)3g010 3g011.jpg (37104 bytes)3g011
3g012.jpg (378233 bytes)3g012 3g014.jpg (63273 bytes)3g014 3g015.jpg (51811 bytes)3g015 3g021.jpg (48115 bytes)3g021 3g025.jpg (26520 bytes)3g025
3g027.jpg (52475 bytes)3g027 3g030.jpg (30252 bytes)3g030 3g035.jpg (57818 bytes)3g035 3g036.jpg (39362 bytes)3g036 3g039.jpg (53442 bytes)3g039
3g041.jpg (55196 bytes)3g041 3g042.jpg (51239 bytes)3g042 3g043.jpg (63738 bytes)3g043
3g044.jpg (52218 bytes)3g044.jpg
3g047.jpg (41613 bytes)3g047
3g054.jpg (51975 bytes)3g054 2g002.jpg (63231 bytes)2g002 2g003.jpg (15041 bytes)2g003 2g005.jpg (76888 bytes)2g005 2g008.jpg (37492 bytes)2g008
2g014.jpg (53906 bytes)2g014 2g025.jpg (27156 bytes)2g025 2g027.jpg (45478 bytes)2g027 2g029.jpg (22594 bytes)2g029 2g034.jpg (46062 bytes)2g034
2g036.jpg (168259 bytes)2g036 2g038.jpg (45898 bytes)2g038 2g045.jpg (61210 bytes)2g045 1g020.jpg (35904 bytes)1g020 1g023.jpg (57332 bytes)1g023
1g029.jpg (32472 bytes)1g029 1g035.jpg (71086 bytes)1g035 1g036.jpg (50647 bytes)1g036 1g037.jpg (54455 bytes)1g037 1g038.jpg (44531 bytes)1g038


  http://www.southbendtribune.com/stories/images/stories/2004/06/09/local.images/stories/20040609-sbt-MARS-A1-Out.sto  
A story and images in the South Bend Tribune; online for a limited time.


The June 4th Artist's Reception for the Transit of Venus Art Exhibit opened the community celebrations and continues through June 30, images/stories/2004.

crowd009.jpg (167374 bytes)
lenore005.JPG (163464 bytes)
poster004.JPG (187829 bytes)
wali007.jpg (172351 bytes)
crowd008.jpg (171571 bytes)
crowd009 lenore005 poster005 wali007

crowd008

On June 5, 2004, The Pub promoted the transit of Venus and hosted Matt Rumley for an outstanding performance.

pub1.jpg (31293 bytes) pub-sign.jpg (37593 bytes) Dsc03138.jpg (37724 bytes)


images/stories/congrats.jpg
U.S. Secretary of Education Rod Paige congratulates the Penn-Harris-Madison Corporation and its families for global outreach related to the 2004 Transit of Venus.

   

JPAGE_CURRENT_OF_TOTAL